DEI-d on Arrival
Delray Beach, Florida, has canceled it's municipal St. Patrick's Day parade for 2027, based on the city attorney's understanding of SB 1134, which doesn't allow county or city governments to "Promote or provide preferential treatment or special benefits to a person or group based on that person’s or group’s race, color, sex, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation." Governor DeSantis' target in all of this was diversity, equity and inclusion programs, but simply calling out DEI by name would have created some fairly significant loopholes in the law, so instead, the language above is in the bill.
The governor, meanwhile, has accused Delray Beach of weaponizing the new anti-DEI measure to make a political point. DeSantis said the city was "engaging in "malicious compliance" in a message he posted on X following the city's cancellation announcement.Leaving aside that the whole point of SB 1134 was to make a political point, another of the bill's goals was: "authorizing a cause of action against counties and municipalities, respectively; authorizing a court to enter a judgment awarding certain relief, damages, and costs." This means that officials can be sued; the state government, not wanting to be in the business of policing counties and cities for compliance with the law, allows other people who think they detect a whiff of DEI in the air to go to court.
And while Florida's Republican-controlled legislature may have written the law specifically to go after programs designed to benefit certain groups, the legislature is not tasked with interpreting the law in court... that's the job of judges. And while their might be judges who understand which groups the legislature is okay with celebrating, and which ones they aren't, and tailor their rulings to support that, asking cities to count on that is asking them to take a fairly significant risk.
This is the problem with attempting to legislate things like this. Governor DeSantis and the Republicans in the Florida legislature can want to target some groups, but not others, but laws can't be written that way anymore. That time passed some 50+ years ago. And so the law can't call out which groups can be honored and which can't. St. Patrick's Day is not a celebration of American's as a whole, it's tied, even if only tenuously, to Irish identity. And if a parade is seen a a publicly-funded benefit to Irish-Americans, Florida law, as of next year, disallows it. The governor can complain about that reading of things, but until he becomes the Florida judiciary, he can't simply declare it unreasonable.
